Liverpool’s Premier League title defence has been met with a reality check from former star Didi Hamann, who described the Reds’ start to the season as ‘average’—a stark contrast to the dominance they displayed last term. Despite only one defeat in six games, Liverpool’s three draws have left them ninth in the table, a position that would have been unthinkable under Jürgen Klopp’s reign. Hamann, who knows the club’s history, was blunt in his assessment: ‘Nine points after six games is pretty average for Liverpool so far.’ His criticism extends beyond the points on the board, highlighting a tactical and physical struggle that has become evident in recent fixtures.
The defeat to Manchester City over the weekend underscored Liverpool’s vulnerabilities. Hamann noted that while the Reds played well before Ryan Gravenberch’s red card, they were ultimately outmuscled by a side that has adapted to life without Pep Guardiola. ‘City were by far the better side overall,’ he said, emphasizing the gulf in quality that has opened up since the Citizens’ title-winning form. The absence of Salah and the injury to Ekitike has further complicated Liverpool’s forward dilemma, with Alexander Isak now thrust into the starting XI. Hamann’s words carry weight given his experience with the club, but they also reflect a broader concern: Liverpool’s inability to sustain their early-season momentum against elite opposition.
The physical mismatch with City was a recurring theme in Hamann’s analysis. ‘Liverpool struggle with physicality,’ he stated, a point that resonates with recent performances where the Reds have been outplayed in duels and aerial contests. The challenge now is whether players like Bradley Barcola can step up to fill the void left by Salah’s absence. With a trip to Brentford looming, the pressure will intensify, especially as the Reds navigate their first major test without their star forward. The draw against Newcastle earlier in the season was a warning sign, and the lack of decisive victories has left Liverpool’s title ambitions hanging in the balance.
Beyond the immediate tactical concerns, Hamann also touched on the psychological impact of Manchester City’s ongoing scandal. While the Citizens have handled the home support with professionalism, they will face heightened scrutiny in away fixtures. Liverpool, meanwhile, must focus on their own issues—whether it’s the inconsistency of their midfield, the lack of a clear striker, or the need to regain their early-season rhythm. The next few games will be critical in determining whether this is a temporary blip or a deeper structural problem. One thing is clear: Liverpool’s title defence is far from guaranteed, and the early verdict from Hamann suggests the Reds have a long way to go before they can claim their place among the Premier League’s elite.
